Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="psychic duck" data-source="post: 428874" data-attributes="member: 48703">Not a great match, but 3/10 is a bit harsh, particularly considering you gave Charteris higher, 5/10 is what I would have given himI would dock him a mark for being out of position during the Haskell try, 5/10, I wouldn&#039;t start him at the World Cup on current formWas my man of the match from a Wales point of view, I want him to play at full back ahead of Byrne, or at least on the bench for the World CupI agree here, on regional form he deserves the position but hasn&#039;t done that well for Wales in his career yet, (is this because the Scarlets style of play suit him more?) still better than any other options we have at centreI&#039;m sorry but look out of place is exactly what he did, as soon as he and Charteris came on the lineout was a mess every time, would struggle to be a first choice at any Aviva Premiership sidenot sure on him at international, I don&#039;t think he&#039;s ready for it, I think James is better at scrums than Bevington although he had an off day yesterdayCharteris is awful, I agree, Ryan Jones should go to lock, Charteris should go back to his rightful place ... the Welsh basketball teamTo be honest I think he struggled at fly half, 7 from 10 is a bit generous</blockquote>

[QUOTE="psychic duck, post: 428874, member: 48703"] [B][B][B][B][B][/B][/B][/B][/B][/B] Not a great match, but 3/10 is a bit harsh, particularly considering you gave Charteris higher, 5/10 is what I would have given him [B][B][B][B][/B][/B][/B][/B] I would dock him a mark for being out of position during the Haskell try, 5/10, I wouldn't start him at the World Cup on current form [B] [B][B][/B][/B][/B] Was my man of the match from a Wales point of view, I want him to play at full back ahead of Byrne, or at least on the bench for the World Cup [B][B][/B][/B] I agree here, on regional form he deserves the position but hasn't done that well for Wales in his career yet, (is this because the Scarlets style of play suit him more?) still better than any other options we have at centre [B][/B] I'm sorry but look out of place is exactly what he did, as soon as he and Charteris came on the lineout was a mess every time, would struggle to be a first choice at any Aviva Premiership side [B][B][/B][/B] not sure on him at international, I don't think he's ready for it, I think James is better at scrums than Bevington although he had an off day yesterday [B][B][B][/B][/B][/B] Charteris is awful, I agree, Ryan Jones should go to lock, Charteris should go back to his rightful place ... the Welsh basketball team[B][B][B][B][/B][/B][/B][/B] To be honest I think he struggled at fly half, 7 from 10 is a bit generous [/QUOTE]

Verification