I'm going to break ranks and say that I quite like Gibson. He's been genuinely outstanding in a crap team.

Ordinarily I think he'd be behind Robshaw, Armand, Wilson and Chisholm but with Robshaw likely to be rested and the others unavailable, he'd be in my thoughts.

What's the verdict on Lewis Ludlow? He's been impressive for Gloucester this season IMO. He's younger than Gibson with greater development potential.